The Blues | Comicbookstore Comic-Kombinat | Independence Day: O Ressurgimento (Independence Day: Resurgence) 2016
Create Game Lists on
FilmCrave home
   Movies  Members
Search +
Searching... Close  
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
  Login Using Facebook

An HP fan theory. Does it make sense?

Location: All Movie Forums / General Discussion / An HP fan theory. Does it make sense?
1 - 2 of 2 1  
Member Comment Date  
Aspiring Actor
A foreign friend and I are big fans of Harry Potter. We actually met at a certain fancon and from then on, we became good friends regardless of our distance. We keep talking about our what-ifs of the book and the movie and we actually came up with a theory that Harry Potter is now immortal. Originally, the prophecy said that the only one who can kill Harry is Voldemort and the only one who can kill the latter is the former. However, now that Voldemort is gone, is there a reason for Harry to die according to the prophecy? Does the theory make sense or it is just probably our imaginations going wild?
6:02 am CT

reply +
report spam +
Aspiring Actor
Interesting point. I looked up the prophecy and for me the key point is "...and either must die at the hand of the other for neither can live while the other survives..."

I think this means that the prophecy doesn't predict an outcome, it merely states that ether Harry or Voldemort is going to die at the hand of the other. In other words, one of the two will kill the other.

Once that has happened, the prophecy is complete. It doesn't say what could happen afterwards, i.e. that somebody else couldn't kill Harry or Voldy later.

The Harry Potter wiki has a good discussion on this:

http://harrypotter.wikia. com/wiki/Sybill_Trelawney %27s_first_prophecy
11:55 am CT

reply +
report spam +

To Post a Comment, Please Sign In
  Login with Facebook
Login with FilmCrave
Become a Member
Sign Up for

Log In
Help on how to log into FilmCrave
Login with Facebook
Login with FilmCrave
What Members Are Doing
Movie Talk
New Movie Reviews
New Movie Lists
Films I've seen in 2018 by aickman
Movies I Want To See by Rod
Top Films of 2015 by Neobowler
Movies I've Watched by Chris Ghost
Movies I've see this year in theaters by Bigbro18
Movies Watched by Sunbutt
Movies of 2013 by Stoney McStonerson
2018: Best to Worst by Nolane




Contact FilmCrave Public Relations    

Advertise and Business

Developer API

Contact Us


About us



Support FilmCrave

FAQ and Help

News and Press

Terms of Use


Are you sure you want to delete this post?